Why does sewage come up through a basement drain?
Because a drainage system under pressure pushes water out at its weakest point, and that point is the lowest opening on the lowest floor it can reach. In a basement that is normally a floor drain, a laundry standpipe or a shower set into the slab.
Drains work on gravity and on having somewhere to send water. Remove either, with a blockage downstream or a main that is already full, and the flow reverses. Your fixtures are then not an exit but an entry, and the lowest one takes the load. That is why a backup so often appears in a basement nobody was using, while the bathrooms upstairs behave normally until they too start draining slowly.
What has to be thrown away, and what can be kept?
Anything porous and absorbent that the sewage wetted goes: pad, carpet, fibrous insulation, chipboard, cabinet bases, soft furnishings, cardboard and paper. Hard, non-porous material stays and is cleaned and treated: slab, block, tile, solid framing, metal, glass and sealed hard plastics.
The reason for the line being drawn there is that contamination goes into porous material rather than sitting on it, and no surface cleaning reaches it. A carpet that was rinsed and dried looks and smells acceptable for a while and is still contaminated inside the pile and the backing. Nobody can verify it, which is why the industry standard is removal rather than cleaning.
Contents follow the same rule, and that is the part that hurts. Books, photographs, cardboard boxes, upholstered furniture and particle board shelving that sat in sewage come out. Hard items, tools, glass, sealed plastics, metal, can be cleaned and kept. A crew photographs and lists what it removes, because that list is what supports a contents claim.
How is the air in the room handled?
The space is closed off with sheeting, and where needed an air scrubber draws air through a filter so dust and odor are not pushed through the rest of the building. Work that disturbs contaminated material is done under containment rather than in an open house.
This matters most in the kind of house that is common in this area, where a basement opens onto a stair with no door and shares its air with everything above it. Cutting out wet drywall and lifting carpet in that situation moves a great deal into the air, so containment and filtration go in first. A crew will tell you which rooms to stay out of and for how long.
What makes one backup job bigger than another?
How far the water spread, how deep it was, how long it sat, whether the lower level is finished, how much had to be removed and disposed of, and whether contents were stored on the floor. No figures are published on this site, and the scope is explained and approved before work starts.
The removal, not the water, is what sets the size. An inch of sewage across a bare slab is a short job: extract, bag the solids, wash down, treat, dry. The same inch across a carpeted basement with a framed partition, a chipboard floor, stored boxes and a particle board kitchen is a strip-out, and disposal of contaminated waste is part of it.
Dwell time changes it again, because material that has been wet for days is both more contaminated and more likely to have growth on it. Illinois requires a written contract signed by both parties for home repair and remodeling work above the threshold set in state law, so you see the scope in writing before a crew starts, and any change to it is agreed in the open. If you have a problem with a contractor, the Illinois Attorney General's consumer fraud hotline can tell you whether complaints have been filed.
Can anything stop it happening again?
A backwater valve on the building drain is the usual answer, and keeping the private lateral clear is the other half of it. Both are plumbing and drainage work rather than restoration, and what is permitted and required is set locally, so check with your local building department.
Older housing is where this comes up most. Waukegan and the towns around it hold a mix of pre-war and postwar construction, and a basement floor drain installed when the house was built may well predate any thought of backflow protection. That is worth knowing before a storm rather than after one. The sewer backup versus flood water guide explains why the two are handled differently, and the heavy rain basement flooding page covers the storm water side.